The 6 ft 2 American guard played college basketball at Seton Hall University, where he started 27 games in his senior year, before transferring to Monmouth University. He averaged 14.1 points, 3.1 rebounds and 2.7 assists per game in the 2021-22 season and earned Third Team All-MAAC honours. Since turning pro in 2022, Reynolds has played in the Dutch BNXT League with Feyenoord, the Cypriot League with Keravnos – where he won both the league and national cup in 2024 – and most recently in the Greek Basket League and FIBA Europe Cup with PAOK Thessaloniki.